Neymar's inclusion in Brazil's World Cup squad has sparked debate, but Carlo Ancelotti's decision is not a sentimental indulgence. It's a calculated gamble shaped by Brazil's attacking injuries, Neymar's national-team record, and his ability to control games in tight situations.
Ancelotti picked Neymar despite his injury history, long absence from the national team, and uneven rhythm since his ACL setback. However, the coach's decision makes sense when considering Brazil's attacking injuries and the specific kind of control Neymar can offer in tight games.
Neymar's record protects him because it's built on his achievements, not just reputation. He's Brazil's all-time leading scorer and has produced in World Cups, including the extra-time goal against Croatia in 2022.
Ancelotti's decision also makes sense when Neymar is judged by the role he can play rather than the player he used to be. Brazil are not getting the explosive left-sided superstar who could carry attacks for 90 minutes. The current Neymar needs management, and Ancelotti's pick becomes easier to defend when considering the right match state, structure, and role for him.
The risk remains heavy because Neymar's name can easily become bigger than his function. If he slows every move, Brazil suffer. If he weakens the press without giving enough on the ball, the midfield carries the cost. However, Ancelotti's pick only works if Brazil treat Neymar as a weapon, not an obligation.
